Skip to main content
Sensible Stats / Established research

The clock on the bench

Noah Okafor needed only a few minutes to decide Leeds–Tottenham. A study of Championship substitutes explains why a coach might start the clock again when a player comes on.

By Elias Vale · Published · 5 min read

A footballer in teal walks away from three navy dugout seats with a vermilion training bib in hand, on a warm ivory background.
A substitute leaves the bench. AI-generated conceptual editorial illustration by Sensible Stats.
In this article

Leeds United sent on Noah Okafor and Harry Wilson in the 77th minute against Tottenham on 7 November. The score was level. In the 79th, Okafor scored the only goal, finishing after getting onto a flick inside the area, according to Leeds’ report. Tottenham confirm the timing and result. The stadium clock had reached the part of the afternoon when people start checking the trains. Okafor’s match had barely begun.

The club reports establish the change and the goal. They tell us little about how Okafor prepared, and two changes at the same stoppage give us plenty of reasons to resist a single explanation. For a coach, the question is what to look for when the next substitute steps on. If you brought on a forward to press, judge the first chance to press. If you wanted someone to receive between the lines, look for the first playable ball. Either task can start well before a goal appears in the record.

References:[2] Leeds United: Official report of Leeds 1–0 Tottenham[3] Tottenham Hotspur: Winning run ended at Leeds

Start at the substitution

Samuel Hills and colleagues followed 17 professional male players at one English Championship club in the latter half of 2017/18. Across 13 home league matches they recorded 35 substitute appearances, including repeat appearances by the same players. They included players introduced at half-time or later. Unused substitutes and enforced first-half injury replacements were outside the sample.

Players wore units combining satellite positioning and accelerometers. The researchers also filmed the preparation before entry. They recorded warm-up bouts separately, then divided each player’s time on the field into five-minute blocks starting from entry. Their statistical models allowed for observations from the same player or match being related, and included playing position and the score when the player came on.

The starting point is easy to miss. Imagine a player entering at 77 minutes. A review that starts at the next round five-minute mark starts at 80. Its first complete block has already lost three minutes of that player’s work. Starting at entry puts those minutes back in view. At Elland Road, that difference would decide whether the goal made it into the opening block at all.

References:[1] PLOS ONE · 14(1), e0211563

The first five minutes were busy

The initial warm-up was longer and covered more ground than each later bout in this group. Later bouts tended to pack more distance into each minute. Those are two ways to measure the same activity. A shorter, brisker bout can be higher on one measure and lower on the other. Before asking a player to do more, it helps to say which column you mean.

In the paper’s descriptive table, substitutes averaged 51 metres of high-speed running in the first five minutes after entry and 31 in the next five. The respective blocks contained 33 and 32 observations. The authors counted running above 5.5 and up to 7 metres per second in that category, with sprinting recorded separately. Their model estimated 19.7 fewer metres in the second block, with a 95% confidence interval from 10.6 to 28.9 fewer. Only four observations remained in the 35-to-40-minute block, so the long tail deserves less weight.

The burst gives the analyst something to look for. It cannot tell a coach whether those metres closed a passing lane or followed a full-back who was already away. A player entering a match that has opened up may have more chances to run. A player asked to hold position may be doing precisely what the team needs while looking rather modest in the running report.

References:[1] PLOS ONE · 14(1), e0211563

A goal has its own timetable

A separate study by Simon Amez and colleagues modelled scoring minute by minute in 2,025 Champions League and Europa League games, covering 2008–2016 and 2011–2016 respectively. For the home team’s first two changes, the estimated scoring association was weaker in the first three minutes than later on. Hills measured individual movement. Amez modelled team scoring. A busy entrance and a team still adjusting can occupy the same afternoon. Neither study identifies what caused Okafor’s finish.

Our pass-value review asked what a completed action makes possible. There is a similar question for a replacement’s first run. Watch what prompts it and what happens to the player they were meant to affect. A forward closing a centre-back on a backward pass might hurry the next ball. The same run, started after the receiver has turned, can leave a useful lane open. These are examples of cues to watch. The report from Leeds does not give us a log of them.

References:[1] PLOS ONE · 14(1), e0211563[4] Amez[2] Leeds United: Official report of Leeds 1–0 Tottenham[5] Sensible Stats: Completion is a modest ambition

Give the newcomer a job you can review

For a coach preparing a forward in a training game, try this untested comparison. Before an entry, name one job and one visible cue, such as closing the centre-back when a backward pass travels. Keep the team’s normal physical preparation. Alternate the usual briefing with the briefing that names the cue, using comparable starting positions and opposition. Where the usual briefing already specifies a cue, use it as the baseline and compare one clearer version.

Start the review at entry and use the first five minutes of each training spell as a common observation window. Record each eligible backward pass and whether the forward is close enough to challenge by the receiver’s first touch. Compare challenges per eligible pass under the two briefings. Keep missed cues in the count and log spells with no opportunity separately. A longer run without a better response gives the staff a reason to revisit the job or the cue. It gives them very little reason to buy a larger spreadsheet.

References:[1] PLOS ONE · 14(1), e0211563[4] Amez[5] Sensible Stats: Completion is a modest ambition

Sources and research status

  1. A match-day analysis of the movement profiles of substitutes from a professional soccer club before and after pitch-entry

    Samuel P. Hills, Steve Barrett, Richard G. Feltbower, Martin J. Barwood, Jon N. Radcliffe, Carlton B. Cooke, Liam P. Kilduff, Christian J. Cook and Mark Russell · PLOS ONE · 14(1), e0211563 · · Peer reviewed

  2. Leeds United: Official report of Leeds 1–0 Tottenham, 7 November 2026
  3. Tottenham Hotspur: Winning run ended at Leeds, 7 November 2026
  4. Amez, Neyt, Van Nuffel and Baert (2021): The right man in the right place? Archived peer-reviewed author version
  5. Sensible Stats: Completion is a modest ambition

Research findings are attributed to the sources above. Illustrative examples, proposed evaluations and interpretations are Sensible Stats analysis.

Tags:SubstitutionsFootball performanceHigh-speed runningLeeds UnitedChampionship

Pass it on

Know someone who enjoys the football behind the numbers? Send them this piece.

From research to forecasts

These findings are not automatic inputs to our model. Explore the accuracy record and methodology or the Premier League forecasts.

Found a mistake? Send a correction.

Established research · · 6 min read

Completion is a modest ambition

A pass can reach its destination without improving anyone’s afternoon. A foundational action-value paper helps explain what completion leaves out—and how a coach might review the next decision.

Source: KDD 2019 · ACM conference proceedings · Peer reviewed

Read the article →